The issue was brought to the forerfront by the owners of the Viewpoint Inn, an 80-year-old roadhouse perched above Vista House at Crown Point in Corbett that is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The owners applied in January for the right to operate the property as a restaurant, five-room hotel and visitor center, thereby allowing them to raise the necessary funds to make critical repairs before winter.

In mid-October, the Columbia River Gorge Commission discussed approving the Viewpoint Inn for such uses, but instead opted for a sweeping policy change that opens up all historic properties for commercial use. As a result, the owners of the Viewpoint Inn were forced to wait another 30 days while staff drafted the new rules. Commission members on Tuesday voted 10 to 1 to approve the new rules. It will be at least another year or so before the policy change is adopted by the federal government, and that approval could be slowed by opponents of the new rule.

By approving the broader policy change instead of just the Viewpoint Inn, however, the commissioners may be inviting a lawsuit by the Friends of the Columbia Gorge. The group opposes development in the national scenic area in general but was reportedly not opposed to reopening the Viewpoint Inn because it was originally built for commercial use. It views the broader policy change as inconsistent with the National Scenic Act. Michael Lang, the lone "no" vote on the commission, feels the same way, according to public comments.