The process was initiated in mid-January, when Genesis signed an agreement to be acquired by joint venture between Alpharetta, GA-based Formation and McLean, VA-based JER for $63 per share. Following a March 29 complaint filed by Drumm Investors LLC in the Chester County Court of Common Pleas alleging a rigged bidding process, Genesis vigorously urged shareholders to vote in favor of the deal.
"No higher offers have been received… any suggestion to the contrary is untrue," the Genesis board said in a letter to shareholders in which it defended the bidding process and also called the Drumm lawsuit "without merit." Northbrook GH LLC, which owns approximately 5% of Genesis stock, then wrote an irate letter to Genesis principals and submitted it to the SEC.
It charged that Genesis "stacked the deck against any other bidder" and said Genesis' letter to stockholders failed to explain that one bidder "was not given the opportunity to raise its bid." In its letter, Northbrook valued the company stock at between $69 and $71 per share.
Genesis responded, again reiterating that the auction process was "active [and] competitive." In a statement, it said that although bidders "had every incentive to submit their best offer, none of the offers was anywhere near Northbrook's purported valuation of the company."
Formation/JER amended its initial agreement, raising its bid to $64.25 a share. In a joint statement, Cia Buckley, president of JER's US fund business, and Arnold Whitman, Formation's CEO, called it a "best and final" price, and added, "If Genesis shareholders do not vote in favor of this transaction at this price, then JER and Formation will focus our attention on other attractive acquisition opportunities."
Days before a scheduled May 4 shareholder meeting, Fillmore jumped in with an offer of $64.75 per share, adding about $10 million to the JV's total price of $1.7-billion. The Genesis board continued to recommend in favor of the Formation/JER offer, but said it would review the Fillmore proposal.
Fillmore later raised its bid to $65.25 per share. Formation/JER matched it, and a shareholder vote was pushed from May 4 to May 11 while Genesis continued to recommend in favor of the JV's offer.
Prior to the meeting date, successive bids reached a seventh round in which Fillmore had raised its offer to $69.25 per share, and the vote was again pushed back to May 30. The Genesis board judged the Fillmore offer "superior" and gave Formation/JER four days to make a counter proposal. Just under the wire, it did, topping the Fillmore offer by $0.10 per share, offering $69.35 per share.
Fillmore charged that it had been prevented "the opportunity to make a superior bid for Genesis for the eighth time," and also said the amended agreement with Formation/JER provides "Formation with a $40-millin termination fee, having the effect of prematurely terminating the auction process for a second time."
Furthermore, Ronald Silva, president and CEO of Fillmore, said that one member of the Genesis board has a personal financial interest in direct conflict with his fiduciary responsibilities to shareholders." Without naming the board member, he said the Genesis board "has repeatedly failed to create a level playing field."
Genesis countered with a statement saying Fillmore's characterization of the process "is demonstrably inaccurate." It said Fillmore had been askednumerous times for a best offer" and had been informed that the JV's latest offer "would likely include an increased termination fee of $40 million."
While the bidding is over, the rancor is not. In a publicly released letter to the Genesis board, received just prior to the Memorial Day weekend, Silva says Fillmore's offer "is hereby withdrawn." The accompanying statement says the company was not provided the opportunity to make a superior bid, although it had expressed interest in doing so. Should Genesis shareholders fail to approve the Formation/JER offer, it said, "Fillmore remains interested in the potential acquisition opportunity."
The transaction approved by shareholders remains subject to regulatory approvals, but is expected to close in July. If it doesn't close by July 31, the price will increase 9% a year, or $0.01710 a day from July 31 through Aug. 31, and by 10% a year, or $0.01900 a day from Sept. 1 until it closes.
The buyout takes Genesis private, and it will continue to operate under the Genesis name. It has 221 skilled nursing and assisted living properties.
By mid-day, following the shareholder vote, GHCI common stock was trading at $68.36 per share on the Nasdaq. This compares with a 52-week high of $69.24 per share, which occurred during the bidding war, and a 52-week low of $43.72 per share.
Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.
Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:
- Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
- Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
- Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
Already have an account? Sign In Now
*May exclude premium content© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.