Given the current landscape, it is easy to conclude that recovery is nowhere in sight. But new research from locally based AMB Property Corp. indicates that rents are expected to rise at a far greater rate than inflation. Rents are very likely to increase in many markets in 2011 and even more broadly in 2012. "We set forth the analysis that leads us to this conclusion as well as our thoughts on the possible magnitude on this cyclical recovery," says David C. Twist, vice president of research for AMB.

Following eight quarters of negative net absorption, national availability reached a historic high of 13.9% at the end of the fourth quarter, and 2009 experienced the worst industrial net absorption on record at a negative 265 million square feet. Encouragingly, says Twist, the negative trend decelerated over the course of the year, slowing to a negative 38 million square feet in the fourth quarter, and new construction came in at an all-time low of 71 million square feet in 2009, as prohibitively low market rents made construction financially unfeasible. "Despite these challenging head winds, our analysis indicates that not only will demand recover, but it has already begun to do so in some submarkets," he adds. "In fact, we may have reached an inflection point in many coastal markets during the fourth quarter, as demand was flat and availability was unchanged at 12.1%."

AMB sees the rental rate recovery taking shape in two phases. First will be the psychological effect between landlords and customers as they anticipate improving fundamentals. "Landlords will subsequently hold firm on rents, while customers will try to lock in longer terms at today's unsustainably low rates," Twist relates. The second phase will be driven by actual improving industrial market fundamentals. As demand gains momentum and availability falls, rents will resume their climb upward, at some point achieving levels consistent with new construction in the market. In many markets this will mean significant near- to medium-term rent growth, finds AMB.

New construction will resume when rents are at or nearing replacement-cost-justified rents--the rents required to finance and pay for the profitable construction of a new building. "Replacement-cost-justified rents provide a useful gauge to judge rent levels when the market is more normalized," Twist explains. "They also serve as the benchmark to the growth trajectory of today's rents." Replacement costs can generally be broken into four different components: land, hard costs (building materials and labor), soft costs(permitting and design) and the developer's profit. When market rent is too low--or cap rates too high--relative to these costs, developers will not commence with new construction, as new development would result in an economic loss to the developer.

"While land sales comps have been relatively scarce in recent quarters, for ease of illustration we assumed that land prices have fallen by 50% from the peak in 2007," Twist says. "We also assume hard costs are down approximately 15%, reflecting lower material and labor costs." While construction costs are down, cap rates have risen by nearly 200 basis points from sub 6%. With a cap rate of 6, developers could have built to a yield of 6.9% in 2007, generating a 15% profit margin. But in order to generate the same profit with today's cap rates, developers would need to build to a yield of more than9%, according to Twist. "Interestingly, the required rent today is very similar to what it was nearly three years ago, given the falling costs and increasing cap rates ($65 cost x 6.9% equals $4.49 in 2007, relative to $50 cost x 9.2% equals $4.60 required rent today)."

However, market rents are down substantially. And most rational developers would not build until rents, costs and yields made economic sense--or were moving decisively in that direction. According to Twist, it is important to note that today's replacement costs will likely begin to grow again over the coming years, thereby increasing even further the rents required to build.

Production, trade and inventories are the principal drivers of demand for industrial real estate, together explaining more than 80% of the variation in historical demand. As such, the respective forecasts for these leading indicators can be used to estimate the future magnitude and timing of demand for industrial real estate. "When we analyze these variables in conjunction with the pipeline of new construction and estimates of new supply, we can forecast the availability rate for the US and individual markets and submarkets," says Twist. "With 2009 experiencing the first contraction in global GDP and the steepest decline in global trade, demand for industrial space hit a record low. However, the current trend and consensus outlook for trade and production, when input into the AMB trade and production model, imply the US and the world should realize more than 100 million square feet and 500 million square feet of net absorption in 2010 and even more in 2011.

If the current consensus estimates and forecasts for production and trade are realized, AMB's model also implies the overall US market would likely see rental rate growth as early as 2011, with equilibrium reached by 2012. So as the US market moves toward 10% availability over the next two years, rents can be expected to reach levels necessary to support new construction. According to AMB data, rents will grow by more than 30% over the next three to four years. The company has developed replacement cost, forecast, equilibrium and rent growth models for markets and submarkets globally. "The rent growth trajectory varies by market and submarket, affected by the spread of current rent to replacement-cost-justified rent, the level of availability relative to equilibrium and the forecast of demand and supply," says Twist. "As mentioned, the coastal markets have likely hit an inflection point in terms of demand and there is virtually no new supply being constructed.

The leading indicators of demand for industrial real estate, such as production and trade, are clearly rebounding, Twist says. And the outlook for these indicators for 2010 and beyond is even stronger. "We expect that these improving economic conditions will fuel recovery in demand, starting in the infill markets. The consensus forecast for global trade and production suggests that more than 500 million square feet of demand could be realized globally in the next few years, driving the availability rate to equilibrium levels in 2012." All of this should drive market rent increases to levels necessary to support new construction requiring several double-digit spikes in the coming years.

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.

Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.