NEW YORK CITY-At midyear, Manhattan’s office leasing market for 2010 is on pace to look more like 2007 or even 2005, CB Richard Ellis and Cushman & Wakefield said earlier this week at media briefings. That comes after the two worst consecutive years of the past decade. Separately, C&W on Thursday reported that the average vacancy rate in 31 CBDs across the US has declined for the first time since ’07.
“The story for New York during the recession and recovery is how much better we’ve performed than the rest of the country,” said Ken McCarthy, C&W’s managing director of research for the New York metro region, at his company’s second-quarter briefing Wednesday. Since January of this year, the city has been adding office-using jobs four times as rapidly as the US overall, he pointed out.
Accordingly, year-to-date office leasing volume is up sharply over the first half of 2009. C&W puts the YTD tally at 12.6 million square feet; CBRE says it’s 11.7 million square feet. By either measure, though, volume is up nearly 100% over the first six months of ‘09 and has a strong shot at climbing well over 20 million square feet for the year.
Matt Van Buren, executive managing director and head of CBRE’s Midtown office, noted that monthly leasing volume over the past 12 months has been right in step with the five-year rolling average of 1.86 million square feet. By contrast, 2008 and last year averaged about 450,000 square feet below the monthly average.
With deals ranging from law firm Proskauer Rose’s 406,000 square feet at SJP Properties’ new 11 Times Square to the New York Liquidation Bureau taking 116,540 square feet at Swig Equities’ 110 William St., the number of transactions over 100,000 square feet is also up sharply from ’09. Only eight of those 21 big deals were renewals, suggesting that tenants are more willing to get out into the market and explore their options, said Joseph Harbert, COO of the New York metro region, at C&W’s briefing.
Added to which, Harbert said, “Despite this long, deep recession, we never got as much sublet space as people anticipated.” Van Buren said at Thursday’s CBRE event that absorption has been “basically flat” YTD, while his colleague, EVP Peter Turchin, noted that sublease space in Midtown has declined by 22.3% this year. “After the market gave back 23 million square feet during the two-year downturn, it has stopped giving it back,” said Van Buren.
In fact, Turchin said, space is being withdrawn from the Midtown market at a rate we haven’t seen before. It’s already ahead of the 2005 total of 4.3 million square feet; YTD the tally is 4.4 million square feet.
However, Midtown finished ’05 with an availability rate of 8.9%. Today, across Manhattan, “availability has been stubbornly stuck at 14% for the past year,” said Van Buren. Helping maintain it at that rate was an increase in Downtown’s availability from 12.4% in May to 15% in June, due to Goldman Sachs’ vacant 1.1-million-square-foot berth at 85 Broad St. entering the totals.
Meanwhile, asking rents for the island overall increased in June, if only by three cents from May’s average of $47.58. Turchin noted that there’s been “tremendous price compression” among the top-tier Midtown buildings, where asking rents in ‘08 were 60% above the average. Today, that price delta has shrunken to 17%.
Over the course of Q2, Manhattan’s three submarkets saw vacancy declines of anywhere from 0.01% in the case of Downtown to 1.04% in Midtown, C&W reported. These three submarkets and the other CBDs tracked nationally by C&W saw a quarterly decline in vacancy for the first time since Q4 ’07, dipping an average 0.23% to 14.8%.
Sixteen of the 31 CBDs tracked by the firm saw quarterly vacancy declines during Q2. That compares to nine of 31 markets, or 29%, during Q1. The largest quarter-over-quarter declines occurred in Atlanta, which declined to 21.5% from 23.2%; Fort Lauderdale, which declined to 18.9% from 20.4%; Phoenix, which declined to 22% from 23.4%; Oakland, CA, which dipped to 16.5% from 17.7%; and Manhattan’s Midtown submarket, which declined to 11.5% from 12.6%.
“Markets throughout the US continue to strengthen, as it becomes strongly apparent that the national vacancy rate for CBDs has peaked,” says Maria Sicola, executive managing director and head of Americas research at C&W, in a release. “Increased leasing activity has attributed to declines in vacancy.”
Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.
Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:
- Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
- Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
- Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
Already have an account? Sign In Now
*May exclude premium content© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.