NEW YORK CITY-In the CMBS world, there’s nowhere to go but up. After hitting rock bottom in 2007, US CRE collateralized debt obligations (CDO) are now showing stability and inching toward recovery, according to a special commercial mortgage report from Fitch Ratings.
“We have been surprised about the speed of the reemergence of the CMBS market and even more surprised by the reemergence of the inquiries about CRE CDOs,” says Huxley Somerville, group managing director at Fitch. This year, the global ratings firm is beginning to receive inquires regarding new CRE CDOs after a near three-year absence.
According to the report, collateral is ranging from seasoned CMBS bonds, newly originated CRE loans and a mishmash of CRE debt. And although CRE CDOs performed poorly during the financial crisis, investors are cautiously optimistic about its reemergence in the marketplace. “This is only speculative, but people are putting some of these pieces on their balance sheet maybe because they believe that there is a good execution now because the markets have come back sufficiently,” Somerville tells GlobeSt.com. “The time is right because people are more comfortable with the story of commercial real estate going forward.”
In their most recent study, Fitch has seen a broad range of collateral types over the last several months, including seasoned B-notes and mezzanine loans; REIT debt; seasoned multi-borrower CMBS bonds and seasoned single borrower CMBS bonds. Out of the three types of CRE CDO loans--including those backed by whole loans (CREL CDOs), those backed by CMBS bonds and those backed by a wide mix of debt--Somerville says newly issued CRE CDOs backed by whole loans may look very similar to traditional multi-borrower CMBS, which may be able to achieve high investment grade ratings.
“The fundamentals are slowly stabilizing,” Somerville says, noting that the key drivers are property cash flow, leverage, pool and portfolio attributes. “It is returning to an even keel,” he says, adding that large loans will still need to be worked out. “There are going to be more defaults going forward, so expect more defaults on loans in 2011 and going into 2012. Not to say that’s bad. Delinquency is starting slow.”
The report notes that proposed CRE CDOs with a wide mix of debt and CMBS bond CDOs with a low average rating are more likely to have their ratings capped at a notch or two above the average rating of the underlying assets. Fitch adds that “in spite of the diversity offered” by different debt types or multiple CMBS bonds, “the commonality of risks inherent” for these loans prevails in the overall credit evaluation. Weaker underlying assets, like lowly-rated, distressed or nonrated CMBS bonds and pools of highly leveraged B-notes or mezzanine loans, are unlikely to be rated by Fitch based upon the “inherent performance volatility of the assets,” the report says.
For future CMBS contributions, issuers may use the CDO funding platform to stabilize property performance. “If you have a floating rate loan, you could keep that vehicle moving by having loans paid off or getting new loans,” Somerville says. “It’s a good execution as far as the floating rate loan if the CMBS transaction monetizes fairly quickly over its life.”
The kitchen sink of CDOs, mixed debt--a mixture of B notes, mezzanine debt and other debt--is thrown off into cash flow, which is accumulated in a CDO and then redistributed according to the bonds that are sold. “I suspect that if someone holds a B note that was 20-cents on the dollar two years ago, it’s now worth 50-cents on the dollar,” Somerville says. “We are starting to see a recovery.”
Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.
Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:
- Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
- Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
- Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
Already have an account? Sign In Now
*May exclude premium content© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.