The initial phase of a growth cycle is under way in Orlando, sparked by local companies that have finally decided to rehire employees. Over the past 12 months, 18,100 jobs were created in the MSA, a 1.8% gain. Local employers were expected to add 7,000 workers during the first quarter alone. By year's end, Orlando employers will move forward in the process of rebuilding staff s depleted by the recession, adding 23,500 jobs, a 2.3% gain compared to 2010 when only 15,600 positions were created. Job growth has prompted greater demand for apartment units, which has resulted in low levels of distress in that sector. The retail and office sectors, however, face higher levels of distress that financiers and investors will have to deal with over the next few years.
Apartment Sector to Outperform
The multifamily sector in Orlando has started to rebound, with vacancy dropping 3.6% over the past year and owners gradually starting to withdraw concessions. No additions to stock and strengthening renter demand combined to reduce vacancy by 70 basis points in Q1 to 7.9%. Owners continue to take advantage of recent improvements in tenant demand, raising asking rents 0.4% in Q1 to $842 per month. Concessions ticked down 20 bps to 7.8% of asking rents, following a 0.6% bump in effective rents to $776 per month. Vacancy will decline even further, dropping 150 bps to 7.1%, after plummeting 260 bps in 2010 on the release of pent-up demand. Asking rents will rise 2.9%, accompanied by a 3.5% increase in effective rents. No projects came on line in Q1 2011 and only 800 units are currently under way in the market. Planned projects total 8,000 units and represent about 7% of existing stock, but none are scheduled to start construction this year. About 1,000 units of multifamily housing were permitted over the past year, approximately two times the number in the preceding year but considerably less than the long-term annual average of 7,000 units. Developers will complete 400 units in 2011, down from last year, when 1,300 rentals came on line.
Although market fundamentals continue to improve, distressed multifamily assets remain a burden on the marketplace. Similar to other major areas in Florida, the market was overbuilt during the boom, especially condo units, and the sharp drop in renters and buyers pushed many properties beyond the breaking point. The strong increase in occupancy and the nominal amount of new supply that has come to market over the past year has greatly slowed the flow of new assets into distress.
Currently, there are no multifamily CMBS properties in Orlando that are in the early stages of distress (30 to 60 days), but there are 14 properties representing close to $200 million beyond that level, with eight already in foreclosure or REO. Investors' appetites have been strong for distressed assets, and many investors remained convinced that the long-term outlook for the market is positive and the discount pricing available on multifamily properties will not last long.
With Orlando's multifamily vacancy rate projected to decline and effective rents projected to increase, the flow of multifamily assets into distress should slow considerably. But those that reach distressed levels will be assets with significant operational challenges that will force foreclosure or REO.
Retail Oversupply
Orlando's retail sector is rebounding significantly slower than the multifamily sector. Retail vacancy is projected to decline by just 10 bps by year's end as the sector continues to negotiate an overhang of supply built during the boom and tepid demand from local retailers. Despite no new construction, the market wide vacancy rate dropped 10 basis points in the first quarter to 10.8%. The market remains in recovery, however, as net absorption of 448,000 square feet in the past year lowered vacancy 30 bps.
The aforementioned job gains improved the performance of convenience- oriented retailers that occupy strip centers along well-traveled commuter routes, resulting in net absorption of 255,000 square feet. Strip centers in Orlando recorded 39,000 square feet of net absorption in the first quarter, pushing down the vacancy rate 50 bps to 11.8%. An additional 180,000 square feet of space was occupied in the past 12 months.
Additionally, store closures totaled 2.7 million square feet in the past year, down from 4.7 million square feet in the preceding 12 months, but substantial numbers of new tenants have not yet emerged. Retailers such as the Aldi grocery chain have opened new stores and are scouting locations, but many others remain cautious regarding expansion, a stance that will limit near-term vacancy improvement. As a result, extremely low completions, not a robust recovery in demand, will contribute most to the projected decline in Orlando vacancy this year. Limited completions will persist beyond 2011 as housing starts remain low and many national retailers scale back footprints.
The tepid improvement in retail fundamentals has resulted in a greater degree of distress in the sector, with more than 40 properties at least 30 days delinquent. Additionally, as demand remains weak and asking rents barely budging from their lows, additional properties are projected to enter the distressed pipeline in the coming months. A majority of distressed properties have already reached foreclosure, with 18 retail properties representing nearly $150 million in loan balances in foreclosure or already in REO. This number is poised to increase substantially, as an additional 16 retail properties, representing roughly $130 million in loan balances, are now more than 90 days delinquent.
Office Buildings Face Biggest Hurdles
Although the Orlando office market is projected to see its first annual increase in occupancy in several years, the sector is dealing with a significant number of distressed assets. After jumping 90 bps in 2010, the vacancy rate will decline 60 bps by year's end to 16.5%, sparked by job growth and minimal new construction. Positive net absorption will total 323,000 square feet, marking the first time in five years the city has recorded positive net absorption. In addition, new stock remains a minimal threat, since only 175,000 square feet of office space will come on line in 2011 and none was delivered last year.
It should be noted that the projected rise in demand and ensuing reduction in vacancy depend upon renewed vigor in the class B and C sectors. A substantial opportunity for improvement exists in lower-tier properties, where vacancy surged to roughly 19% last year, 400 bps more than the class A rate. A sizable decline in B and C vacancies could occur in 2011 as conditions improve for the creation of small businesses, which oft en occupy lower-cost, lower-quality office space.
Unfortunately for local owners seeking to capitalize on these fundamental gains, rent growth will lag improvements by several quarters. Asking rents will rise only 0.5% to $21.15 per square foot, while effective rents will increase 1% to $16.84 per foot by year's end. More than 30 office buildings in the metro area are currently in a state of distress, representing loan balances of approximately $300 million. While this represents a very small percentage of the total office market in Orlando, their impact on values and cap rates has been substantial. Similar to other property types, office properties in distress have quickly made their way to foreclosure and then REO and have been marketed at steep discounts to investors. With numerous assets currently more than 90 days delinquent, the pipeline of REO assets in the Orlando area will increase throughout 2011. This should continue to keep values down, even as fundamentals slowly recover. As these distressed assets disappear from the market and fundamentals demonstrate substantial improvement by 2012, valuations should increase.
GlobeSt.com News Hub is your link to relevant real estate and business stories from other local, regional and national publications.
Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.
Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:
- Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
- Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
- Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
Already have an account? Sign In Now
*May exclude premium content© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.