If ever a shopping center was proof that bad things can happen to good projects, it's Mesa Ranch Plaza in Mesa, AZ. Local developer Diversified Partners LLC had an idea for a uniquely positioned retail center to serve the emerging regional Hispanic community. Anchored by Pro's Ranch Market and La Curacao, along with a concentration of specialty retail and services specifically targeted toward that demographic, the 214,400-square-foot project had everything it needed to become one of the region's dominant destinations for this particular market segment.

The year was 2008 and the center was about to open. Pro's Ranch Market signed on to lease about 61,000- plus square feet, La Curacao was committed to a 100,000-square-foot box, and the remaining shop space was also pretty well leased, around 70%. After going through the entire building process, signing a lease, agreeing on TIs and getting keys in hand to start putting in registers and inventory, La Curacao pulled out of the deal at the last minute. The result? Keybank, the lead lender on the project, foreclosed on the center in 2010.

"This was a well-conceived, well designed and well located project," says Glenn Smigiel, an investment and sales specialist in the Phoenix office of CB Richard Ellis Inc. "The developer did nothing wrong and did a very good job with it. Unfortunately, having a 100,000-square-foot box not paying rent killed them, and they wound up losing." Smigiel explains to Distressed Assets Investor that La Curacao pulled out because "they were concerned about the global market in general," noting that it was just around the time the market had turned. "The project was built for approximately $30-plus million and just sold for $19.1 million."

That $19.1-million price tag recently went to buyer Reddy Development of Scottsdale, AZ. The buy, which also includes a developable pad site, was an all-cash deal. The center went for about $2 million more than expected, thanks to competitive bidding, says Philip Voorhees, a senior vice president with CBRE's national retail investment group.

According to Smigiel, who worked with Voorhees on the sale, 34 bidders in total stepped up to claim the 55% vacant property. Sean Asmus, vice president of development at Reddy Development, tells DAI that the company plans to re-tenant and hold the property. And, says Smigiel, Reddy already has a lot of leasing activity going on, even on the 100,000-square-foot box, which, "might have to be broken up, but so far, there's a lot of interest from a combination of Hispanic oriented stores and some traditional retailers of soft goods, which is great."

One of the factors that attracted Reddy was the combination of the right stores in the right location. Smigiel cites the high concentration of Hispanic consumers in a three-mile radius around the center. Out of more than 170,000 people, nearly 41% are Hispanic. Within a one-mile radius, Smigiel says, the percentage rises to 60%. Pro's Ranch "was the right store in the right location and it does extremely well in sales," he adds. According to Voorhees, "This deal shows the huge amount of investor demand for distressed properties. We're seeing intense bidding activity on almost every REO property we take to market." Mesa Ranch Plaza traded at a fairly low cap rate and $90 per square foot. "Depending on how you look at it, it was either a great price or very expensive because the current cash flow makes the cap rate low, yet on a price per square foot basis, it sold for about half of replacement cost."

Smigiel too has seen high numbers of interested buyers for REO properties but points out that this one was a little higher than others. For example, his Phoenix investment team recently sold a retail center in North Scottsdale, AZ that was anchored by high end grocer AJ's, that was 66% leased. That center, he said, had 22 offers. "Good quality centers that have a real good story behind them are getting a lot of bids," he says. Voorhees and Smigiel also worked with Todd Goodman, Pat Toomey, Megan Read and John Read, along with CBRE's local Phoenix investment team of Bob Young, Steve Brabant and Rick Abraham, as well as retail specialists Kevin Schuck and John Rehling. Bruce Francis and Dana Summers of CBRE Capital Markets in Phoenix represented Reddy Development. A local expert recently told sister publication GlobeSt.com that the lenders held a note of $26 million to $28 million on Mesa Ranch Plaza, which means that they recovered more with this sale than the industry average for REO retail properties. Industry research indicates that lenders are recovering 60 to 65 cents on the dollar, on average, which Smigiel says is a good approximation. Mesa Ranch Plaza is located at 1036-1118 E. Southern Ave. In addition to Pro's Ranch Market, the center is leased to Anna's Linens, T-Mobile and a host of local and regional small tenants. "There was a lot of risk for the buyer coming into the deal because of the vacancy, but he felt confident he could be successful with the center," Voorhees says.


GlobeSt.com News Hub is your link to relevant real estate and business stories from other local, regional and national publications.

Continue Reading for Free

Register and gain access to:

  • Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.