The cloud of distress is slowly dissipating over Southern California's sunny skies, although some areas of concern still present challenges to real estate owners. The supply-constrained apartment sector and flourishing industrial property market present the least challenges to owners and financiers, while some retail and office assets, particularly in the Inland Empire and Orange County, have bigger hurdles to overcome. While these distressed assets present challenges to current owners and banks, they also present opportunities to buy properties at deep discounts.

While the US multifamily sector continues to see the highest rate of distress among the four major product groups, in dense and supply-constrained Southern California, the market has been the best performer and continues to exhibit the lowest levels of distress. Among the four major metro areas in SoCal, the Inland Empire has the highest multifamily vacancy rate, at slightly above 5%, with San Diego exhibiting a low 3.2% vacancy. The extremely tight rental market has resulted in significant rental growth over the past 12 months, which has helped many properties that were teetering on the verge on delinquency improve their fundamentals and move their loan status to performing.

While there are few delinquent assets for investors in Orange and San Diego counties, opportunities exist in the Inland Empire and Los Angeles, where the increased sprawl, condo conversion bust and tepid economic recovery has negatively impacted a greater number and scope of multifamily properties. The current delinquency pipeline for these areas shows a strong concentration of assets in severe distress (90 or more days) and a few smaller and mid-sized properties in the earlier stages of distress. The continued improvement in local multifamily fundamentals will slow the movement of assets into the distressed pipeline, but those already in distress will most probably be taken to market as the lenders look to capitalize on the active sales market and move the properties off their balance sheets, especially as multifamily recovery rates in Los Angeles remain above 85%.

The retail sectors in Los Angeles, Orange and San Diego counties are already showing signs of recovery, as vacancy rates decline and more retailers lease in urban infill areas throughout that region. Vacancy in Los Angeles County will decrease 20 basis points this year to 6.1% after holding steady in 2010. The metro's average vacancy rate peaked at 6.5% during the second quarter of last year. In Orange County, vacancy will fall 80 bps to 5.7% in 2011, compared with a 20-bps uptick in 2010. Overall, retailers will absorb 1.1 million square feet of dark retail in the county. In San Diego, vacancy will fall 70 bps this year to 4.8%, due primarily to a lack of planned development.

Meanwhile, retail fundamentals in the Inland Empire, which continue to deteriorate, have led to significant distress in Riverside and San Bernardino. More than a third of all distressed properties in the Inland Empire are retail as the strip and power centers built in the path of development in the two counties have been unable to maintain operations in the face of the flailing single-family housing market. Retail distress is so severe in the Inland Empire that the total dollar volume of distress exceeds the dollar volume of retail distress in Los Angeles and is the fourth largest in the country behind only Phoenix, Las Vegas and Chicago.

With improving fundamentals and limited new construction, the retail markets in Orange County and San Diego have seen relatively limited retail distress, although there are a few dozen properties in severe trouble (60 or more days) that may enter the market in the coming months. Many of these assets, however, are in the second or third ring of suburbia, and the halt in new housing construction limits their near-term fundamental improvement potential.

The retail sector, in general, has remained relatively healthy in Los Angeles but has not been immune from the general economic struggles and store closings, and more than 120 retail properties are currently in distress. For investors, Los Angeles provides the greatest source of distressed retail opportunity, although with recovery rates for lenders trending toward 80%, the pricing discount is not as strong as it was just six months ago.

The Southern California office market is the most distressed sector of the major property types with more than 260 assets representing some $5.7 billion labeled as distressed in the four metros in Southern California. Nearly half the assets and 60% of the distressed dollar volume is in Los Angeles, led by the MPG portfolio in Downtown, where a lack of leasing improvement and the inability of MPG to afford necessary tenant improvements has the buildings operating as zombie properties and heading the wrong way down the distressed pipeline.

MPG properties have also been a focal point of distressed opportunity in Orange County, where the extreme increase in vacancy in the marketplace after the housing bust led to numerous REO/foreclosures and a fertile environment for opportunistic investors. Pricing has become more competitive with the increased investor activity, but with vacancy projected to decrease 110 basis points by the end of the year and projected rent growth, buyers are still circling opportunities when they become available. While distressed opportunities are also plentiful in the Inland Empire, its tertiary office market status and its continuing rising vacancy rate is keeping investors away at this point.

San Diego's CBD has fared relatively better than most urban cores across the country, but there are several dozen distressed office properties in the suburbs, particularly in the northern submarkets. The lower price point on these assets, coupled with slightly better fundamentals in the north, will make it a very attractive market for private, opportunistic distressed buyers.

The Los Angeles industrial market remains one of the tightest and best performing markets in the country with a vacancy rate below 5% and the first signs of increasing rents during the first half of the year. But, in spite of solid fundamentals, overleveraging and functional obsolescence has led to the largest amount of distressed industrial assets in the country by property and by dollar volume. As a percentage of overall industrial space, the distressed portion remains extremely low, but there are opportunities for investors. While many of these obsolete properties will be converted to other uses or completely redeveloped, there are pure investment opportunities mixed in, but the competition is extremely stiff and pricing is not as advantageous as in other markets.

Distressed industrial opportunities in both San Diego and Orange counties are limited as both markets have maintained relatively healthy fundamentals. Any potential owner/user assets, however, are moving toward REO/foreclosure, and investors with tenants in hand may see attractive opportunities in these markets. The significant dislocation in the Inland Empire industrial market after the housing bust and recession has provided numerous distressed opportunities for investors. These range from newer, speculative developments to older but functional warehouse space. It is important to distinguish the stronger West Inland Empire market from the weaker East Inland Empire market. While vacancy in the Riverside-San Bernardino area remains above 10% for warehouse space, investors are still attracted to the area because of its proximity to Los Angeles and the significantly more attractive pricing and yields offered.


GlobeSt.com News Hub is your link to relevant real estate and business stories from other local, regional and national publications.

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.

Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.