Milwaukee's economic recovery will continue to gain ground, supported by a moderate and sustainable pace of hiring. Based on recent trends, job creation will reach 3,800 new positions in 2010, an increase of 0.5% from 2009, matching the forecasted national growth rate. Though gains have been relatively modest, the resumption of employment growth this year remains a welcome change after losing a combined 65,000 jobs between 2008 and 2009. The majority of employment sectors in the metro area have either stabilized or resumed growth as of the third quarter. Year-to-date in 2010, expansion has been most robust in the leisure and hospitality segments, and a recent decision by Harley-Davidson to remain in Milwaukee should preserve jobs over the extended outlook. Additionally, the impact of the housing market downturn on the local economy has been moderate when compared to other markets around the country. As of Q3, the median existing home price in the metro area was within 10% of peak levels, compared to a drop-off of roughly 25% nationwide.

Commercial real estate fundamentals softened across property sectors in recent years but appear close to stabilization. So far in this cycle, the volume of properties falling into distress has been limited in the Milwaukee marketplace, a trend that should continue as capital markets ease further in 2011 and strengthening job growth ultimately gives way to recovery in operations. As of late September, known distress in the local commercial real estate market totaled $354 million, ranking at the bottom when compared to other Midwest markets. For perspective, known distressed dollar volume in the city falls behind Kansas City by more than 25%, St. Louis and Minneapolis by approximately 50% and 70%, respectively, and is 95% short of levels reported in Chicago.

A relatively small correction in home prices through the downturn has kept homeownership out of reach of many local families. This has limited the loss of renters to the for-sale market and helped to keep apartment vacancy within a relatively tight band throughout the recession, which in turn has minimized distress. As of third-quarter 2010, apartment vacancy in the Milwaukee metro area stood at 4.8%. This figure is well below the national vacancy rate of 7.2% and just 110 basis points above the most recent low point, the US vacancy rate remains 170 bps higher than its last cyclical trough.

Some softening in occupancy may occur in the final months of2010, particularly in the class A sector, as a significant amount of new supply comes online, however, growing employment rosters and a thinning construction pipeline next year will ultimately give way to vacancy reductions and rent growth. Transaction velocity in Milwaukee will receive only a modest boost from distressed apartment sales, with REO listings likely to remain low in the coming months. While apartments account for the most significant share of distress reported in the marketplace through the down cycle, few troubled loans remain unresolved and CMBS apartment delinquency currently rests at zero.

Market wide, relatively low vacancy rates, steady rents and the resumption of job growth will bolster apartment investments over the next several months. In-state buyers will likely continue to target operationally sound properties in the near-in City East submarket and affluent areas in suburban Waukesha County. A handful of

distressed properties will trade, though these assets typically contain 30 units or fewer and are priced between $35,000 and $45,000 per unit, compared to the overall median of almost $50,000 per unit.

Through the most recent economic downturn, the local office sector experienced the sharpest increase in vacancy of the core commercial property types, and it now accounts for the second-largest share of distressed dollar volume in the marketplace. Since late 2007, office vacancy has spiked 660 bps to 19.7%. While asking rents declined by only 2% over the same period, concessions have skyrocketed, resulting in an 11 % drop in effective rates.

Despite this weakening, overall distressed office dollar volume, in absolute terms, remains somewhat limited in Milwaukee when compared to other major markets across the nation. Furthermore, the local CMBS office delinquency rate currently stands at less than 3.5%, well below the national rate of 6.6%, suggesting REO activity will remain minimal over the near term. There have been owners who ran into challenges in recent years due to softening fundamentals, but only a few have resulted in reported distressed property sales. It also remains unlikely that distressed office sales will claim a significant share of velocity over the next year, though a few medium-sized deals could emerge based on the roster of troubled assets. As of the third quarter, most of the properties considered distressed ranged in size from 100,000 to 300,000 square feet, while those already reclaimed by banks were much smaller, at around 50,000 square feet or less.

After climbing in 2008 and early 2009, retail vacancy has held relatively stable over the past 18 months, hovering around 15%. Rents have continued to decline, however, and effective rates in the market currently fall 7% below their most recent cyclical peak of a few years ago. Nonetheless, distress remains minimal in the Milwaukee retail market, and the majority of trouble can be associated with maturing debt as opposed to operational issues.

Within the CMBS sector, just one loan is in foreclosure, and only one Milwaukee property has been reclaimed by its lender. Another two loans have fallen behind by 90-plus days, while three loans have encountered problems due to balloon payments that became due upon maturity. While distressed retail property sales remain few and far between, multi-tenant sales velocity has surged in 2010 after stalling for much of last year. More buyers have emerged to acquire well-located shopping centers anchored by grocers or dining establishments with guaranteed leases, both at cap rates above 8%. Meanwhile, the lack of REO properties has encouraged more aggressive multi-tenant investors to take on high-vacancy listings, where buyers with management and leasing capabilities can achieve double-digit first-year yields. Single-tenant investors are seeking properties with slightly elevated risk and cap rates, targeting assets occupied by top-notch, national-level tenants in secondary and tertiary submarkets, as initial yields in these areas currently average around 7.75%,50 bps to 60 points higher than those for similar infill product.


GlobeSt.com News Hub is your link to relevant real estate and business stories from other local, regional and national publications.

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.

Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.