NEW BRUNSWICK, NJ-Is New Jersey the new nirvana for multi-family developers, with apartment construction spreading off the waterfront and into suburbia at last, or is the situation for builders still only “marginally improved?” The question repeatedly pushed to the fore at the heavily-attended RealShare NJ conference Tuesday at The Hyatt Regency here.
“New Jersey is still the highest-barrier-to-entry state for developers, any sector,” said The Kislak Co.'s president Robert Holland in a morning session on “The Multi-family Market: New Trends and Uses.”
But LCOR's Brent Jenkins, speaking as a member of the “Power Panel,” said he thinks the state's traditionally high regulatory barriers and local resistance to apartment construction are dissipating: “Things are really changing when, in a place like Montclair, you can get approval for 400 rental apartments. “ LCOR is a co-developer with Pinnacle of the upcoming first phase of the Centro Verde mixed-use complex in downtown Montclair, which includes 259 apartments.
“Municipal executives are realizing that in order to be successful in attracting (tax) ratables, you have to create a 24-7-type atmosphere, with housing, office, entertainment, all of it,” said Jenkins. “They are getting it.”
Mack-Cali CEO Mitchell Hersh said “the jury is still out” as to whether municipalities are learning to lay out the welcome mat to multi-family developers. His company is in the midst of a massive portfolio shift from primarily office holdings to multi-family.
“Several municipalities are moving to create overlay zoning, creating neighborhoods that are microcosms, with some office as well as multi-family, particularly in transit-oriented areas,” Hersh noted to the crowd of more than 400 real estate professionals. Hersh said antipathy to any development that might add school-age children to the population appears to be unyielding in other locales, however.
“It is a political issue,” Hersh said. In many of the state's more than 560 localities, he said, “people get very accustomed to the quality of life – and they fear change.” He said developers have to proceed with educating municipal leaders and residents concerning the different nature of “today's tenants – Millennials, young, well-educated, professionals, empty-nesters, etc...”
Eric Witmondt, CEO of Woodmont Properties, said anti-apartment sentiment is a carryover from long ago, the 1950s through the 1970s when some towns had “bad experiences” with willy-nilly construction. “There is still a barrier” in some places because of this, he said.
Actually, said Carl Goldberg, who heads the Roseland apartment-development division of Mack-Cali, the picture varies significantly from municipality to municipality. Before Roseland was acquired, Goldberg recounted, his company had a “long and difficult history” with a multi-family project in Parsippany, where attitudes were “tainted” against apartment development.
On the other hand, Golberg said, “We built a project in Verona, and five years ago when we asked if we could build a second, the mayor said: 'When can I do the ribbon-cutting?
Both Woodmont Properties and the AvalonBay Communities are surging ahead with multi-family development in the Lehigh Valley area of Pennsylvania, panelists noted.
“In some of our deals in the Philadelphia area, they want school-age children, because they now have schools with empty desks,” said Ronald Ladell of AvalonBay. By contrast, he said, it is a foregone conclusion that planning for one-child-per-unit will not be approved in most New Jersey communities.
Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.
Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:
- Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
- Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
- Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
Already have an account? Sign In Now
*May exclude premium content© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.