Photo by YouTube/NBC News |

WASHINGTON, DC–For the first president debate, the candidates Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump dispensed with the pleasantries almost immediately. They began swinging at the first question on job creation and never ceased throughout the 95-minute debate, held at Hofstra University in Hempstead, NY. From that first question, Clinton and Trump quickly pivoted into a quasi free-for-all (with debate moderator NBC News veteran Lester Holt struggling hard to control of the flow) that ranged from ISIS, cyber warfare, Trump's personal taxes, Clinton's email server scandal to whether stop-and-frisk is constitutional.

Their answers have since been picked over, fact-checked and refuted ad nauseam.

Except one interesting opinion that Trump voiced — an opinion that should be of great interest to the commercial real estate industry.

No Support for Carried Interest

First, though, let's make clear one fact: Trump is a New York developer and businessman and some of his policy proposals would be welcome by this group. Not all however — in one key respect he has gone completely off script: his tax plans call for the elimination of carried interest, an important tax policy for private equity investors. During the debate, he repeated that call.

But that is old news.

During the debate Trump warned viewers — over 100 million of them according to projections, rivaling the Super Bowl — that the US economy is in a bubble. “A big fat ugly bubble” is how he put it.

When interest rates rise, “we will see some very bad things happened,” he warned.

As it often the case with Trump, this statement was accompanied by part controversy and part conspiracy. The reason for the bubble, he said, was that the Federal Reserve “is doing political things.”

Given that no credible and independent economist has ever agreed with the notion that the Fed is a political creature, we can dispense with that thought train.

But the idea that the US economy is in a bubble because of the low interest rate policy of the Fed? That does give one pause.

Cheap Money Leads to Bubbles

Commercial real estate valuations have recovered more than nicely since the recession. Some will say that the fundamentals support that; critics will say the valuations have been artificially inflated because of low interest rates. To be sure, fundamentals are strong in many assets classes but it is equally true that investors have been placing money in any asset class that can deliver a better yield than US Treasuries. Which has driven up prices. Indeed, just last week Fed Chair Janet Yellen said that some Fed governors were concerned about commercial real estate valuations.

This is not a situation unique to CRE either incidentally — it can be seen in many sectors from the unicorn tech prices that investors are willing to pay to residential housing prices.

The Fed believes that the economy is strong enough for interest rates to begin to rise — soon, it says! Very soon! — without risk of implosion. So we shall see very quickly which view is correct.

More than 300 of the industry's leading national investors, REITs, banks, private equity firms, asset management firms and other institutions will join us as we explore the market conditions behind the trends at this year's RealShare National Investment & Finance, scheduled for Oct. 5 and 6 at the Roosevelt Hotel in New York City. Learn more.

Photo by YouTube/NBC News |

WASHINGTON, DC–For the first president debate, the candidates Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump dispensed with the pleasantries almost immediately. They began swinging at the first question on job creation and never ceased throughout the 95-minute debate, held at Hofstra University in Hempstead, NY. From that first question, Clinton and Trump quickly pivoted into a quasi free-for-all (with debate moderator NBC News veteran Lester Holt struggling hard to control of the flow) that ranged from ISIS, cyber warfare, Trump's personal taxes, Clinton's email server scandal to whether stop-and-frisk is constitutional.

Their answers have since been picked over, fact-checked and refuted ad nauseam.

Except one interesting opinion that Trump voiced — an opinion that should be of great interest to the commercial real estate industry.

No Support for Carried Interest

First, though, let's make clear one fact: Trump is a New York developer and businessman and some of his policy proposals would be welcome by this group. Not all however — in one key respect he has gone completely off script: his tax plans call for the elimination of carried interest, an important tax policy for private equity investors. During the debate, he repeated that call.

But that is old news.

During the debate Trump warned viewers — over 100 million of them according to projections, rivaling the Super Bowl — that the US economy is in a bubble. “A big fat ugly bubble” is how he put it.

When interest rates rise, “we will see some very bad things happened,” he warned.

As it often the case with Trump, this statement was accompanied by part controversy and part conspiracy. The reason for the bubble, he said, was that the Federal Reserve “is doing political things.”

Given that no credible and independent economist has ever agreed with the notion that the Fed is a political creature, we can dispense with that thought train.

But the idea that the US economy is in a bubble because of the low interest rate policy of the Fed? That does give one pause.

Cheap Money Leads to Bubbles

Commercial real estate valuations have recovered more than nicely since the recession. Some will say that the fundamentals support that; critics will say the valuations have been artificially inflated because of low interest rates. To be sure, fundamentals are strong in many assets classes but it is equally true that investors have been placing money in any asset class that can deliver a better yield than US Treasuries. Which has driven up prices. Indeed, just last week Fed Chair Janet Yellen said that some Fed governors were concerned about commercial real estate valuations.

This is not a situation unique to CRE either incidentally — it can be seen in many sectors from the unicorn tech prices that investors are willing to pay to residential housing prices.

The Fed believes that the economy is strong enough for interest rates to begin to rise — soon, it says! Very soon! — without risk of implosion. So we shall see very quickly which view is correct.

More than 300 of the industry's leading national investors, REITs, banks, private equity firms, asset management firms and other institutions will join us as we explore the market conditions behind the trends at this year's RealShare National Investment & Finance, scheduled for Oct. 5 and 6 at the Roosevelt Hotel in New York City. Learn more.

Want to continue reading?
Become a Free ALM Digital Reader.

Once you are an ALM Digital Member, you’ll receive:

  • Breaking commercial real estate news and analysis, on-site and via our newsletters and custom alerts
  • Educational webcasts, white papers, and ebooks from industry thought leaders
  • Critical coverage of the property casualty insurance and financial advisory markets on our other ALM sites, PropertyCasualty360 and ThinkAdvisor
NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2024 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Erika Morphy

Erika Morphy has been writing about commercial real estate at GlobeSt.com for more than ten years, covering the capital markets, the Mid-Atlantic region and national topics. She's a nerd so favorite examples of the former include accounting standards, Basel III and what Congress is brewing.